Emission Rights

Emission allowances and the EU ETS: rules, duties and changes

The EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) is the most important European climate instrument with direct consequences for business. One allowance confers the right to emit one tonne of CO2. The total number of allowances falls every year. Any operator caught by the system needs a permit, must have its emissions verified and must surrender enough allowances each year. The Dutch Emissions Authority (Nederlandse Emissieautoriteit) supervises the system and enforces it strictly.

The short answer

  • The EU ETS has been in place since 2005 and rests on Directive 2003/87/EC.
  • The ETS sectors must cut their emissions by 62 per cent by 2030 compared with 2005.
  • In the Netherlands some 350 companies fall under the stationary ETS, plus around 2,000 ships since 2024.
  • The verified emissions figure must be entered in the registry by 31 March at the latest; allowances may be surrendered up to and including 30 September.
  • Surrendering too few allowances triggers a fixed penalty of EUR 100 per tonne, indexed.
  • Free allocation for CBAM sectors is phased out from 2026 and reaches zero in 2034.
  • A second system for buildings and road transport (ETS2) has been postponed from 2027 to 2028.

How the EU ETS works

The system operates on a cap-and-trade principle. The European Union sets a ceiling for the total emissions of the installations covered. Allowances are issued within that ceiling.

The cap falls each year by a linear reduction factor. That factor is 4.3 per cent per year from 2024 up to and including 2027. From 2028 up to and including 2030 it is 4.4 per cent. This creates scarcity, and scarcity creates a price.

Companies obtain allowances in two ways. Part of the volume is auctioned. Part is allocated for free on the basis of benchmarks, in order to limit carbon leakage to countries outside the EU. Electricity producers must in principle buy all their allowances.

Allowances are tradable. A company that reduces more than it needs to may sell the surplus. For the purposes of financial regulation, emission allowances are classified as financial instruments, which has consequences for anyone trading in them professionally.

Who is covered

The stationary ETS applies to large industrial installations above certain thresholds. Think of electricity generation, refineries, steel, cement, lime, glass, ceramics, paper and parts of the chemical industry.

There are two extensions on top of that. Aviation within the European Economic Area has been covered since 2012. Since 2024 large seagoing vessels are covered as well. In 2025 shipping companies surrendered allowances for their emissions for the first time.

If your installation is covered, an emissions permit is mandatory. That permit sits alongside the permits required under environmental and planning law and the obligations arising from environmental law.

Monitoring, reporting and verification

We are Always Ready to Assist Our Clients

Law & More has at its disposal a dedicated team of multilingual lawyers

Reliable measurement is the heart of the system. The annual cycle runs as follows.

  1. Permit and monitoring plan. You submit a monitoring plan for approval by the Dutch Emissions Authority. It sets out how you determine your emissions, by which method and within which margins of uncertainty.
  2. Updating. If your installation, your fuel or your measurement method changes, the plan must be updated. In practice this is often overlooked, and it regularly leads to disputes.
  3. Emissions report. You draw up an emissions report for each calendar year.
  4. Verification. An independent accredited verifier assesses the report.
  5. Registration. The verified emissions figure must be entered in the EU ETS registry by 31 March at the latest.
  6. Surrender. Up to and including 30 September you surrender at least as many allowances as the verified figure shows.

The role of the Dutch Emissions Authority

The Dutch Emissions Authority (Nederlandse Emissieautoriteit, NEa) is the independent national authority for the EU ETS. Its remit is broad.

The NEa issues the emissions permit and approves the monitoring plan. It manages the Dutch part of the EU registry and distributes the free allowances. It supervises the system, carries out inspections and attends measurements.

There is little room for manoeuvre on enforcement. Failure to surrender allowances on time attracts a fixed penalty of EUR 100 per tonne, indexed to the European harmonised index of consumer prices since 2013. That penalty is not linked to culpability, and the Court of Justice has confirmed that it cannot in principle be moderated. The obligation to surrender the missing allowances also remains in place.

For other breaches the maximum is EUR 450,000, or ten per cent of annual turnover where that figure is higher.

CBAM: the carbon border mechanism

CBAM puts a price on the embedded emissions of certain imported goods. The mechanism is governed by Regulation (EU) 2023/956, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2025/2083.

CBAM applies to six product groups: cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen.

The transitional phase ran from 2023 up to and including 2025 and imposed reporting obligations only. The definitive phase began on 1 January 2026. The key points are these:

  • A threshold applies of 50 tonnes of imported CBAM goods per importer per calendar year. That exemption does not apply to hydrogen and electricity.
  • Imports above the threshold require the status of authorised CBAM declarant.
  • Sales of CBAM certificates start on 1 February 2027, for imports from 2026 onwards.
  • The declaration for 2026 and the surrender of the certificates must be completed by 30 September 2027 at the latest.
  • From 2027 a quarterly holding requirement applies of 50 per cent of embedded emissions.

What changes in the years ahead

Phasing out free allowances

Free allocation to CBAM sectors is being withdrawn as a mirror image of the introduction of CBAM. This follows from Article 10a of Directive 2003/87/EC, as amended by Directive (EU) 2023/959. The percentage of free allowances develops as follows.

YearShare of free allocation
202697.5%
202795%
202890%
202977.5%
203051.5%
203139%
203226.5%
203314%
2034 onwards0%

The largest single step falls between 2029 and 2030. Anyone taking investment decisions now would do well to build that step into the business case.

ETS2 for buildings and road transport

A second, separate system will run alongside the existing one. ETS2 covers fuels for buildings, road transport and additional sectors, mainly smaller industry. The obligation rests with the fuel supplier, not with the end user.

Regulation (EU) 2026/667 has postponed the start from 1 January 2027 to 1 January 2028. Monitoring and reporting are already under way. In the Netherlands more than 300 companies fall under ETS2. The revenues feed the Social Climate Fund, among other things.

Frequently asked questions

Can a penalty imposed by the NEa be reduced?
For the fixed penalty for surrendering too few allowances, that is in principle not possible. For other breaches there is more room, because the NEa then takes account of seriousness, repeat offending and consequences.

As an importer, do I need to do anything if I stay below 50 tonnes?
If you remain below the threshold, the CBAM obligations do not apply. You must, however, be able to demonstrate that. If you exceed the threshold, the rules apply to all goods imported in that year.

What happens to my free allowances after 2034?
For the CBAM sectors free allocation will then have ended entirely. All the allowances you need will have to be bought.

Contact

Do you have questions about your emissions permit, an enforcement decision of the NEa or your CBAM position? Our environmental law solicitors assist companies with permits, objection and appeal proceedings, and with the interaction with the CSRD and ESG reporting. Law & More has offices in Eindhoven and Amsterdam and works in Dutch and English. Please feel free to contact us.

Do you want to know what Law & More can do for you as a Dutch Law Firm in Eindhoven?
Then contact us by phone +31 40 369 06 80 or go to the contact page for more information:

Sustainabilitylaw