Innovation Image

Sustainable innovation: subsidies, state aid, IP and sandboxes

Sustainable innovation rarely runs into a prohibition. It runs into rules written for existing technology. Anyone bringing a new process, product or energy concept to market faces four legal questions at once. Can I obtain a subsidy without falling foul of the state aid prohibition? Who owns the invention? May I depart from rules that never contemplated my solution? And how does an innovative party get a seat at the table in a procurement procedure? This article deals with those four questions.

9.6 / 10Client rating on Klantenvertellen, 81 reviews
08:00–22:00Available Monday to Friday; Saturday and Sunday 09:00–17:00
€250–350Hourly rate of a lawyer, excl. VAT, agreed in advance
In short

The short answer

  • A subsidy is rarely free of strings. Every scheme carries conditions, deadlines and recovery risks.
  • Government support for an undertaking is in principle prohibited state aid, unless an exemption or an approval applies.
  • Decide who owns the intellectual property before the first publication. Repairing this later is expensive.
  • The Environment and Planning Act (Omgevingswet) contains an experimentation provision allowing temporary departure from the rules.
  • In procurement, the innovation partnership offers room for development and purchase within a single procedure.
01

Subsidies and tax schemes

The Netherlands has a broad set of instruments for sustainability and innovation. The Netherlands Enterprise Agency administers most of them. They include the SDE++ for renewable energy and CO2 reduction, and the WBSO for research and development work. Alongside these sit tax schemes such as the energy investment allowance and the environmental investment allowance.

Legally, four points are decisive every time.

  1. Sequence. Many schemes require you to enter into the commitment after the application. Sign earlier and the entitlement lapses.
  2. Deadlines. Application windows are short and often phased. A late application is not assessed on its merits.
  3. Accountability. The award decision imposes obligations on delivery, reporting and timing.
  4. Recovery. Where obligations are not met, the subsidy may be set at a lower amount or recovered, with interest.

A refusal or a lower final award can be challenged by way of objection. The period for doing so is short. Lodge your objection in time, even while discussions continue. On the funding side, read more under financing.

02

State aid

Support from a public authority to an undertaking that is capable of distorting competition and that adversely affects trade between Member States is prohibited in principle. That prohibition is contained in the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.

There are ways through. The General Block Exemption Regulation exempts certain categories of aid from notification. In addition, guidelines on aid for climate, environmental protection and energy from 2022 apply.

Since 25 June 2025 the Clean Industrial Deal State Aid Framework applies as well. That framework replaces the transitional provisions of the earlier crisis and transition framework. It addresses five areas: the roll-out of clean energy, electricity costs for energy-intensive industry, the decarbonisation of industrial processes, manufacturing capacity for clean technology, and de-risking private investment. The framework runs until 31 December 2030.

The risk lies with the recipient. Aid granted unlawfully must be repaid with interest, even where you acted in good faith. Have the state aid basis set out in advance in the decision or in the agreement.

03

Intellectual property

In sustainable technology, several forms of protection run into one another.

  • Patents for inventions that are new, inventive and industrially applicable. Protection requires novelty, so do not publish or present before filing.
  • Trade secrets for process know-how you do not wish to disclose. Protection requires demonstrable measures, such as confidentiality arrangements and restricted access.
  • Plant breeders' rights for new plant varieties, relevant in bio-based applications.
  • Copyright and database rights for software, models and measurement data.

In collaborative projects with knowledge institutions or chain partners, ownership is the most frequent source of conflict. Agree in advance who owns the results, who receives which licence, and what happens on early termination. Deal with background knowledge contributed by the parties as well.

We are Always Ready to Assist Our Clients

Law & More has at its disposal a dedicated team of multilingual lawyers

Mind the interaction with subsidy. Some schemes require publication or dissemination of results. That may collide with a patent strategy.

04

Room to experiment

Innovation often stalls on rules that assume existing technology. Environment and planning law offers a way out.

Article 23.3 of the Environment and Planning Act contains an experimentation provision. It allows temporary departure from rules in force. The experiment must contribute to a safe and healthy physical living environment, to the quality of that environment, or to better procedures and decision-making. Experiments are designated by order in council (algemene maatregel van bestuur). An experiment is subject to a fixed duration and to conditions.

The practical route runs through the competent authority. Approach the municipality or the province early, with a concrete proposal and a reasoned statement of the objective. See also environment and planning law.

In the energy field, the Energy Act (Energiewet), which entered into force on 1 January 2026, provides a new framework. That Act replaces the Electricity Act 1998 (Elektriciteitswet 1998) and the Gas Act (Gaswet). Among other things it anchors the energy community and widens the sharing of energy data. That creates room for new market models.

At European level the use of regulatory sandboxes is expanding. In a sandbox you test an innovation under supervision within a defined framework. It remains a supervisory arrangement, not a free pass; liability towards third parties continues to apply.

05

Public procurement

Government is often the first large purchaser of sustainable innovation. Procurement law determines how you can win that contract.

The innovation partnership is the most targeted instrument for this. The procedure is designed for solutions that are not yet on the market. It combines development and purchase in a single process. Its basis lies in the European procurement directive and it is worked out in the Public Procurement Act 2012 (Aanbestedingswet 2012).

You can also steer through the award. Sustainability may be weighed in the award criteria, provided those criteria are linked to the subject matter of the contract and are measurable. Requirements as to performance are possible too, on emissions or circularity for example.

If you see a specification that in substance points to an existing technology, react in time. Questions in the information memorandum (nota van inlichtingen) and timely interim relief proceedings (kort geding) are the proper route. Wait too long and you forfeit your rights.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

May I start before the subsidy has been granted?

Often not. Many schemes require that you enter into commitments only after the application has been submitted. Check this scheme by scheme.

What happens if aid turns out to have been unlawful?

The aid must be repaid with interest. Good faith on the part of the recipient is in principle no defence.

Can an experiment let me depart from European rules?

No. The experimentation provision concerns national rules. European obligations, such as the nature directives, continue to apply in full. Are you working on a sustainable innovation and do you want the legal route settled in advance? Contact Law & More. We advise on subsidies, state aid, contracts, intellectual property and procurement. Our offices in Eindhoven and Amsterdam work in Dutch and English.

Contact

A question about your own situation?

Email us a few lines about your question at info@lawandmore.nl. We will let you know whether we can help and what the next step is.

Law & More, Marconilaan 13, 5612 HM Eindhoven (+31 40 369 06 80) and visiting location Pietersbergweg 291, 1105 BM Amsterdam (+31 20 369 71 21). Available Monday to Friday 08:00-22:00, Saturday and Sunday 09:00-17:00.

This page provides general information and does not replace advice on your specific situation.

Sustainabilitylaw
Scroll to Top
Questions?
Practical questions

Answers to practical questions about Law & More. This assistant does not give legal advice.

What does a lawyer cost?

Our hourly rate is 250 to 350 euro for a lawyer and 300 to 400 euro for a partner, excluding VAT. A one-off consultation costs 300 euro including VAT. We always agree the rate with you in advance. More about our fees

Is the first meeting free?

No. The first meeting is a paid consultation of 300 euro including VAT, in which you receive a directional answer to your question. Book a consultation

Do you work on legal aid?

No. Law & More does not take on matters on a legal aid basis (toevoeging), except criminal-law duty (piket) cases. The Juridisch Loket can help you find a lawyer who does.

Which matters do you take on?

In the field of sustainability we work in environmental, planning, energy and corporate law, among other areas. We generally do not take on matters with a financial interest below 5,000 euro. We decide ourselves whether we take on a matter and are not obliged to account for that decision. All services

When can I reach you?

Monday to Friday from 08:00 to 22:00 and Saturday and Sunday from 09:00 to 17:00. Call +31 40 369 06 80 or email info@lawandmore.nl. Please note that we work with limited staff in the evenings and at weekends, so call-back requests are often only handled during regular office hours. We only call back if we are interested in your matter.

Where are you located?

Our office is at Marconilaan 13 in Eindhoven. In Amsterdam we meet you by appointment at Pietersbergweg 291. Meetings can also take place by phone or video.

How quickly will I get a reply?

We assess every message ourselves and reply when your matter fits our services, usually within one business day.

Which languages do you speak?

We advise in Dutch and English. For first contact our staff also speak German, Spanish, Italian, Polish, Russian, Arabic and Turkish. Not all languages are available at all times.

Can I get legal advice here?

No. We only give legal advice in a paid consultation or within an engagement, so that we can assess your situation properly. Book a consultation